lunes, 6 de septiembre de 2010

Topic 2 - Personality, Perception and Attribution + Attitudes and Values

Key words: Personality, Attribution, Perceptions, Interaction, Pygmalion effect, Interactional Psychology, Theoretical approaches, Expectations,
 SUMMARY:
We have to understand the individual as the origin of every study within the organization, because it is formed by different perceptions, personalities and perspectives.


We start saying that there are perceptions of things, values and tasks, as people within the organization and it depends of their own attitudes, values, ethics and skills. But the constant interaction of those differences, influence the organizational behavior in general (interactional psychology).
The concept of Personality, includes the individual characteristics of the human been, and it is determined by heredity or the personal experiences within a particular context or environment.


We can find many theoretical approaches of personality, but we are going to expose the most applicable in organizational behavior:


*Trait Theory: It assumes that different traits and characteristics of a human been, compose his own personality and his character. This theory proposes 5 types of personalities: Extraversion, Agreeableness, Conscientiousness, Neuroticism , Openness


*Psychodynamic Theory: Key Concepts of Freuds Psychodynamic Theory


*Humanistic Theory: Need for self-actualization

*Integrative Approach: Assumes that the personality and their characteristics depend of the combination of individual factors (early years of life) and a set of situational variables.

Perceptions are the ways how the situations are perceived from different perspectives. They are also, the individual’s view of the world, and there are many perceptions as the number of persons in a specific situation. However, within the organization, people have to reach a “purple zone”, where perceptions of all the members of one group may interact and crate outputs.

The interaction and feedback between the perceiver and the target we can find some barriers that can damage the final message and the results of interaction. They could be: Stereotypes, errors, judgments, etc.


The perception principles are:


- Selective perception: People focus their attention in what is important for them the most.


- Stereotypes: They function as generalizations


- First impression error: Last opinions based on initial experiences


- Projection: People tend to overestimate the people who share their own beliefs.


- Self-fulfilling prophecy: Confirm perceiver’s expectations

Attributions refer to the causes of one thing that happen in a specific situation. Attributions might be internal (personality) or external (situation).


“Heider first made the argument that people tend to overweight internal, dispositional causes over external causes—this later became known as the fundamental attribution error (Ross, 1977)”. (Source: Ross, L. (1977). The intuitive psychologist and his shortcomings: Distortions in the attribution process. In L. Berkowitz (Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology (Vol. 10, pp. 173–220). Orlando, FL: Academic Pre).


ATTITUDES: This concept may be defined as a psychological tendency (positive or negative), related with the perceptions of the individual, and influence the human been behavior. This concept is explained in a better way by the ABC model:


Affects: Emotional part, indicators and feelings


Behavioral intentions: Observed behavior


Cognition: Attitudes lies on personal beliefs and experiences.

Taken from: http://www.mikethementor.co.uk/images/CBC_ABC_model.gif

The attitudes are formed by direct experiences or social learning (culture, family, others).


In the organizational concern, “It relates to how you feel about your work and your approach towards work. Hence, work attitude behavior is intangible. You cannot see it. Your colleagues cannot see it. But people can feel it”. (“Work Attitude Behavior and Work Behavior Attitude – Are They The Same?”)


VALUES: It is related with HOW YOU SHOULD BEHAVE. Some cultures, groups and organization have their own code of values that may be used as a guide for their components. Instrumental values (Acceptable behaviors to achieve goals) and terminal values (Goals themselves).

QUESTIONS:



1. Please explain, using your own words, the concept of Pygmalion Effect.

Pygmalion effect can be defined as a perceptual tendency, which involves some actors in a specific process that requires a target's performance. This concept means: if the perceptions of one leader or perceiver are positive, then the outputs and results of some task will be positive too, and the target's performance will reach the proposed objectives. 
Those initial perceptions are influenced by internal factors, such as personal experiences, personality and beliefs of the perceiver, but also by external factors related with the context. 


* What are the potential implications, uses, or challenges that this effect may pose for organizations engaging into international operations that require the understanding of diverse cultural contexts? Can you use this concept to explain the relationship between national and organizational cultures?

Within the organization, this concept are focused on managerial tasks, because the managers are considered as the leaders of the organizations, and their perceptions (positive or negative) influece the most, the perceptions of their subordinates or their groups of work.
In the international scope, the are some challenges by the organizations and managers, and they are related with the diversity of cultures, because there are a lot of perceptions and differences in the workplaces today, and the principal challenge for the managers is to coordinate all of them, in order to generate value and create outputs for the company.
"Community development and leadership development are integrally intertwined. A leader cannot develop new leaders and keep them engaged without clear contributions to make to a greater good. A leader cannot have any enduring impact in a community without engaging its people directly in co-leadership in vision, design, and execution of efforts." (Retraining Ourselves in Thought and Action: A Thematic Exploration of Leadership Literature, David T Gortner. Anglican Theological Review. Evanston: Winter 2010, ProQuest database.).
 
The Pygmalion effect, related with the concept of national culture fits perfectly to explain the variations and the influence of internal and external factor within the organizations, because managers' behaviors and perceptions are influenced by internal perceptions and learnings that he got from their national culture and he makes value adopting those perceptions within the organizations and transfering them to the teamgroup and subordinates. Example: Chinese national culture of building relationships between cooworkers, is adopted at the workplace also, and it allows the target's performance and accomplishment of goals. 




Topic 1 - Organizational behavior + national and organizational culture

Key Words: Organization, Individual behavior, norms, environment, national culture, organizational culture, globalization, groups, adaptation, consistency, cultural dimensions.

SUMMARY:
Individual is the basis for the analysis and the interaction of different individuals form a specific group that generally has common interests or a common goal as minimum.


People belong to a group because they have the need to perform, in order to accomplish with integration purposes (This is the motivation of the individual behavior) and those groups are constantly interacting each other (“group dynamics”). “Members in such a highly interconnected context are motivated to maintain a close relationship with other group members for task completion and goal achievement” .(Source: EBSCO database: Chun-Hsi Vivian Chen and Ya-Yun Tang: “Exploring the Mediating Effect of Group Cohesion in Multilevel Analysis”).


The human behavior is affected by a lot of variables such as:


*Internal Perspectives: Belong to the person as individual and they are inside each person, according their past experiences, thoughts, feelings and needs. They may be different due to the basis of each culture adopted in earlier years of the life.


*External Perspectives: They are outside the person and depend of the external events or environment.
We have to take into account both perspectives within an organization, because they might modify the performance of each employee or a specific group of employees. For example: If one person is low-paid by a company, this person will not be enough motivated to do his job, and this situation affects the quality of the job and then, the quality of the organization.


DEFINITION OF ORGANIZATION:


“Social unit of people systematically arranged and managed to meet a need or to pursue collective goals on a continuing basis. All organizations have a management structure that determines relationships between functions and positions, and subdivides and delegates roles, responsibilities, and authority to carry out defined tasks. Organizations are open systems in that they affect and are affected by the environment beyond their boundaries.” . (Source: www.BussinessDictionary.com)
Based on this definition, we can conclude
The organization may be compared as:


-Clockwork: Every part that composes it has to fit and has one specific task, in order to complete the organization’s goals.


-Snake pit: It is not an easy task: It is complex and has many daily obstacles.

All organizations have two factors that compose it as a whole and they are denominated: formal and informal. The first ones involve the visible part of the companies with their mission, vision, objectives proposed since the beginning, products and services offered by the company, symbols, language, ceremonies, etc; however, there are a lot of invisible factors that people can recognize only with they work for the company or interact with all members and experiences inside the company (feelings, attitudes, values and beliefs). The combination of all those components forms the organizational culture as a whole, and this is an important concept:


Organizational culture is “likely to how the organization makes decisions, communicates and structures its roles and relationships”(International management and culture” Chapter one) and this is what makes a company different from others, even if they offer the same products. For this reason, it is very hard to copy by the competence and it belongs to the competitive advantage of the organization and their members.


There are a lot of different values and perspectives within a company but the company have establish a model to be followed for all their components in order to achieve some goals; However, we can find some “patterns” in terms of a nation or country and it influences the company behavior very much: They share customs, values and common beliefs, even though there exist other factors as the external ones.


Many authors propose many theories about the cultural dimensions that we have to take into account when we study a specific culture, but we are going to adopt the Hofstede’s dimensions:
-Power Distance


-Individualism vs. Collectivism


-Masculinity vs. Feminity


-Uncertainty Avoidance


-Long term vs. Short term orientation

QUESTIONS:


1. Considering the conference "Dealing with Cultural Differences" by Nick B. Meyer, choose 1 cultural dimension and use an hypothetical but realistic situation - or real one - to illustrate the business implications of cultural differences. you may not use situations or examples already discussed in class or in the conference.


Nick B. Meyer is a specialist studying cultural dimensions and he says in his conference presented in the EAFIT University, that there is not a “world culture”, that this is a complex concept changing every days and everywhere. However, nowadays we have to be aware of those cultural changes due to the globalization processes. That is why he explains the cultural dimensions and how different countries have adopted their own but have introduced new elements as well. One of the most important is:


• Uncertainty avoidance: “It indicates to what extent a culture programs its members to feel either uncomfortable or comfortable in unstructured situations. Unstructured situations are novel, unknown, surprising, different from usual. Uncertainty avoiding cultures try to minimize the possibility of such situations by strict laws and rules, safety and security measures, and on the philosophical and religious level by a belief in absolute Truth; 'there can only be one Truth and we have it'. People in uncertainty avoiding countries are also more emotional, and motivated by inner nervous energy.” (Geert Hofstede™ Cultural Dimensions).

Illustrated examples: Israel is a county marked by many social and political disturbs, due to the immigration of Jewish people from many countries and the historical conflict with Arabian world for their territories and their culture maintenance. As we can see in the chart, this culture has a high degree of uncertainty related with future changes and future situations due to the historical context. People avoid taking future decisions because some factor as the war.

Taken from  http://www.geert-hofstede.com/hofstede_israel.shtml



Taken fromhttp://images.google.com.co/imgres?imgurl=http://decabo.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/01/foto-guerra-palestina-israel





CORPORATE CULTURE IN THE ORGANIZATIONS


All organizations make part of certain type of environment that shares common characteristics or variables. However, it is not composed by only one or two or three actors, but is composed by a lot of organizations, variables and independent actors that affect the relationships, the internal policies and decisions within them as individuals.
Organizations are composed by individuals with different beliefs, customs and values, however, all the organizations need to have clear their own “style” that makes it different from other companies, that’s why I agree with the assumption that every organization has a corporate culture: They establish objectives and targets and they have to start to hire employees with common characteristics in order to achieve those proposals: that is why the companies take enough time to look and select their employees before hire them.


When people are working together they establish some ties that make them a group or team, looking for common goals; but not all the persons need to have the same attitudes and perspectives, they need to use those differences to reach a common proposal, and this I not an easy task, because the company must have a well structured framework to make this possible and this is one of the reason because we have to take into account that if one company is more complex and it has more employees and elements this organizational culture and code needs to be stronger than a simple and easy one.

It think that the organizational culture cannot change totally if we want to keep it strong, because if we do, the company would change their internal and external image and it would bring negative dissonances with their employees, their objectives and their performance in general. But the company needs to improve their culture all the time and it has to adapt it according the continuous changes around the new world, because there is an important concept called “competition” and “globalization”, within a bigger scope. But this concept is not new, Freeman (1892) wrote that there is not innovation without change and recently the specialists says: “A culture that spurs innovation allows for natural work teams to build as often called communities of practice joining people of congruent intellectual interests (Amin and Roberts, 2008). "It is very important to have internal partners ...,"


Taken from http://www.beyondlean.com/images/corporate%20culture%202.jpg